[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Skip to Main Content

Latest News

Advertise Here
October 18, 2010
Volume 88, Number 42
p. 6

Vaccine Liability

Lawsuits: Supreme Court will decide whether law protects drugmakers from claims over injuries

Glenn Hess

The Supreme Court heard arguments in a case brought by the Bruesewitzes on behalf of their daughter Hannah, center, who is diagnosed with residual seizure disorder. Michael Henninger/Newscom
The Supreme Court heard arguments in a case brought by the Bruesewitzes on behalf of their daughter Hannah, center, who is diagnosed with residual seizure disorder.
  • Print this article
  • Email the editor

Latest News

October 28, 2011

Speedy Homemade-Explosive Detector

Forensic Chemistry: A new method could increase the number of explosives detected by airport screeners.

Solar Panel Makers Cry Foul

Trade: U.S. companies complain of market dumping by China.

Novartis To Cut 2,000 Jobs

Layoffs follow similar moves by Amgen, AstraZeneca.

Nations Break Impasse On Waste

Environment: Ban to halt export of hazardous waste to developing world.

New Leader For Lawrence Livermore

Penrose (Parney) Albright will direct DOE national lab.

Hair Reveals Source Of People's Exposure To Mercury

Toxic Exposure: Mercury isotopes in human hair illuminate dietary and industrial sources.

Why The Long Fat?

Cancer Biochemistry: Mass spectrometry follows the metabolism of very long fatty acids in cancer cells.

Text Size A A

The Supreme Court heard arguments last week in a dispute over whether a law designed to compensate families of children who have severe reactions to vaccine inoculations also shields drug manufacturers from most related product liability claims.

The justices are considering an appeal by the parents of a Pittsburgh woman who want to sue Pfizer’s Wyeth unit over the seizures and developmental disabilities their daughter suffered allegedly as a result of the company’s diphtheria, tetanus, and pertussis (DTP) vaccine, which she received as a six-month-old baby in 1992.

Robalee and Russell Bruesewitz initially sought compensation in 1995 but lost in a special court Congress set up to hear vaccine-injury claims under the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986. That panel said the parents had failed to show that the seizures were caused by the vaccine.

The Bruesewitzes then filed a lawsuit against Wyeth based on Pennsylvania tort law. But in August 2007, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania ruled that their claim was preempted by the 1986 law. In March 2009, the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Philadelphia agreed.

To help ensure a stable vaccine supply, the statute protects manufacturers from most lawsuits over vaccine-related injuries or deaths. Legal action is preempted “if the injury or death resulted from side effects that were unavoidable even though the vaccine was properly prepared and was accompanied by proper directions and warnings.”

David C. Frederick, a lawyer representing the Bruesewitz family, told the justices last week that the federal law does not bar all lawsuits, especially those filed when the harmful side effects were avoidable. He said a safer version of the vaccine existed, but Wyeth continued to market the riskier vaccine until 1998 because of costs.

Manufacturers have a duty to provide “the safest possible products in light of what the science holds,” Frederick said. Wyeth lawyer Kathleen Sullivan countered that Congress intended to preempt state-law claims because “the manufacturers were being driven out of the vaccine business, imperiling the nation’s vaccine supply.”

Chemical & Engineering News
ISSN 0009-2347
Copyright © 2011 American Chemical Society
  • Print this article
  • Email the editor

Services & Tools

ACS Resources

ACS is the leading employment source for recruiting scientific professionals. ACS Careers and C&EN Classifieds provide employers direct access to scientific talent both in print and online. Jobseekers | Employers

» Join ACS

Join more than 161,000 professionals in the chemical sciences world-wide, as a member of the American Chemical Society.
» Join Now!